How to Stop Squeaky Orthotics (6 Easy & Cheap Solutions)

A few weeks ago I published a video of me on Instagram running down the road with THE worst squeaky insoles in a pair of trainers ever. Honestly, they were driving me nuts, It’s here if you want to see it. A couple of days I walked into the gym making the same noise and seriously the whole room turned around. Enough was enough – it was time to find out how to stop my orthotics from squeaking.

Person walking in pink trainers along a path

I got on the phone to podiatrist David Eardley from Peacocks Medical Group who make orthotics and asked his advice on how to stop my insoles from squeaking.

Why Do Orthotics Squeak?

A mistmatch in fit between your shoe and the orthotics is the most common cause of this.

‘If your orthotics and your shoes fit well together this won’t happen and you won’t get ‘insoles squeak’,’ he told me. ‘But if there’s a gap at any point between the orthotic and the shoe the orthotic will move and that’s what causes squeaking.’

To fix the problem you can therefore plug any gaps that might cause the problem, or, try and reduce friction if your orthotic does move around in the shoe.

The good news there seemed to be lots of solutions that could help do this and silence my squeaky orthotics….

This post contains affiliate links and I get a small commission if you make a purchase. Buying from these links does not involve any extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

6 Easy Fixes to Stop Orthotics Squeaking

1. Apply Some Talcum Powder

First easy fix – simply sprinkling talcum powder inside the bottom of the shoe and placing the orthotic back on top can reduce friction and stop the squeak. ‘It doesn’t always work though,’ says David. ‘And you do have to keep renewing it.’

Also, make sure you walk around a bit with the shoes after you add the talc before you leave the house. It can puff up – which, if you’re wearing tights or socks will leave white fluffy marks!

If you want to try it though, any kind of baby powder or talcum powder will do.

Order the classic Johnson’s Baby Powder here.

See you don’t even have to squeak your way to shops with this tip!

2. Remove the Insole

Orthotics squeak when they move around the shoe too much, so, if your trainer has removable insole, try taking that out (if you haven’t already) then place the orthotics back in.

This can lower the orthotic in the shoe so it fits better making it more likely to stay still so you say goodbye to your squeaky insoles.

If your trainers are a bit loose generally, it might also help to learn the lace lock that helps tighten things up as this can stop your foot moving around.

You’ll find the instructions here. 

3. Velcro May Silence Squeaky Orthotics

Because the problem is the orthotic moving in the shoe putting something in place to stop that movement can also help.

David suggests sticking a strip of velcro, or a similar type of sticky tape, furry side up on the base of your running shoes, then sticking a second postage stamp sized piece on the base of the orthotic at the point you can feel the movement or gap.

If you’re lucky the two will stick firmly enough to reduce friction and your squeak will stop.

4. Try Some Moleskin

If the squeak occurs at the heel, stick a square of moleskin on the bottom of your shoe. It cushions the orthotic and can stop the problem.

You can buy moleskin in rolls and cut it to fit.

5. Grab a Dryer Sheet

Yes, those things you put in the tumble dryer to reduce static in your washing. These also help your orthotic grip the sole of your shoe more effectively.

Cut the dryer sheet to the shape of your orthotic and put it under in your shoe.

Pop the insole back on top and the friction should be reduced enough to stop your shoe inserts squeaking. 

Any dryer sheet, like Downy or Bounce, that you use in your laundry can also be used to tackle squeaky orthotics.

If you don’t have any in the laundry supplies, you can order dryer sheets here.

6. Try Silicone Spray

If the tips above don’t work, you probably don’t have big enough gaps between the orthotic and the shoe to be causing problems. So, try spritzing the base of the orthotic with food grade silicone spray.

Silicone almost acts as a lubricant which means that if the orthotic does move slightly within the shoe, it slides rather than squeaks.

The reason I suggest this one last is, if you do have gaps that need to be filled you might find your foot sliding around a bit in the shoe.

Try brands like CRC Food Grade Silicone.

More Complicated Solutions for Squeaky Insoles

The ‘easy fix’ tips above can stop insoles from squeaking in most cases – but if they don’t work, you might have to try something a bit more complex.

Get the Orthotic Properly Fitted

If you’re getting new orthotics, then the absolute best solution is to send your shoe along to the orthotic manufacturer so they can fit the inner sole to your shoes as well as your foot.

Sadly that one is too late for me, and possibly you but…

If you haven’t had your orthotics that long, then speak to the manufacturer as they might be able to thin the orthotic, usually done at the heel, to change its fit in the shoe and prevent the squeaking.

Change Your Trainers

At this point I was inspired – I thought the moleskin trick sounded like my best solution and I was ready to go get some, but then as part of my day job I went to find out about a new treatment for arthritis called Apos therapy which uses specially crafted shoes to alter the way you walk reducing pain.

And this brought me this last suggestion

Buy a shoe designed to correct pronation, take out the stupid squeaky insoles and see what happens.

You see part of my visit to Apos involved having a gait analysis to see how I walked, I scored really well which surprised me and so we started discussing my pronation – at this point I happened to mention, ‘the squeak’.

The physiotherapist took one look at my trainers and said ‘they are a shoe designed to correct your pronation, I actually don’t think you need your orthotics in them. Maybe a few years ago when trainers weren’t as good at correcting gait you did, but now, in this shoe, with your level of pronation, I don’t think you actually need the orthotics.’

Pretty purple trainers - but check out the different laces.
Magic Squeak Stopping New Balance Shoes

That was about six weeks ago and that very night I took the orthotics out of my shoes.

I admit I was nervous. I can’t even remember why I got the orthotics in the first place but I know it was because something had started to hurt. My first run was fine, my second run was fine – and, while I’m by no means racking up the miles right now, the other runs have been fine too – so, hooray. I no longer squeak.

If you therefore want to attempt to remove your insoles altogether, you might want to consider buying a shoe that aims at keeping the foot more stable.

Some of the Best Shoes for Pronators include

From Salomon

The Salomon XR Mission which is particularly good for those with a lot of overpronation.

From Asics

Asics have a couple of pronation shoes in their range including the GT Xuberance and the Kayano. Check both of these out here. 

From Mizuno

Another suggested model is the Mizuno Wave Paradox which offer a lot of support and stability.

Insoles for Everyday Wear

Oh and while we’re on the subject of all things insole related. While I might have divested myself of my trainer boost, I’ve had to add some added support to my daily walking plimsols.

I’m still trying to rack up 10,000 steps a day on top of my normal exercise and I admit it’s taking it’s a toll on my feet a little bit. When I walk in my shiny new black plimsols I’m definitely feeling twinges that signify the return of my old friend plantar fasciitis. 

This condition happens when the thick pad of tissue that runs along the bottom of the foot gets inflamed and it’s very, very painful – and wearing insoles that support the arch of the foot can help. Knowing I’d had problems, the team behind some insoles called Sole Footbeds sent me some to try.

These insoles use the heat generated as you walk to mould the inner sole to the base of your feet and give your arches some extra support. It’s early days, but so far, so good and I’m not getting so many twinges.

You can also use them in running shoes so if you’re having foot woes they might be a good in-between solution between getting customised orthotics and nothing. As an added bonus, they don’t seem to make any sound either

Footbeds aren’t the only ready-made orthotic-type insoles out there. There are lots of different types of pre-made orthotics aiming to provide support for running or reduce risk of plantar fasciitis.

Check out this selection here if you’re looking to buy a new pair. I’m also a fan of the Powerstep insoles.


Who is The Wellness Nerd?

My name is Helen Foster and I’m a health journalist and wellness author. Publications I’ve written for include Women’s Health, Reader’s Digest, Body and Soul, Good Health at the Daily Mail and more. I have also written 16 books on health and nutrition.

Leave a Comment